Wednesday, November 09, 2005

Starhawk: Ruminations on the Concept of Evil


...when we condemn the willingness to kill others in order to pursue one's own ends, we also need to acknowledge that willingness is widespread. What "ideology of evil" motivated Tony Blair to join the United States in pursuing a war in Iraq that has killed tens and perhaps hundreds of thousands of civilians, guilty only of being born in the wrong country at the wrong time? Could he please explain to me why, if it is evil to kill civilians on a bus or in the London tubes, it is okay to kill civilians in bombing raids on major cities? Why acts that are "evil" when done by small groups of extremists are moral and good when pursued by governments and armies? The willingness to sacrifice others for one's own good is not limited to war. It is also part of the context of endemic violence woven into our current political and economic system. The UN Commission on Children tells us that six million children a year die from the policies the International Monetary Fund imposes on third world countries, that result in lack of access to health care and clean water. In a neighborhood near mine, young men kill each other in drug and gang wars born of hopelessness and despair. The very integrity of the earth's climate and life support systems are in jeopardy from global warming, while efforts to address this crucial life issue are stymied deliberately by a few defending their own economic interests.

And while this constant killing goes on, we are distracted and desensitized. Turn on the television any night of the week, and notice how our imaginations are colonized by violence. Crime shows, jewel thieves, cop shows, war stories, battle scenes march endlessly across the screen, filling our inner vision with images of mayhem, broken bodies and blood, as if we can only be entertained by vicarious pain and endlessly replayed dramas in which someone else dies and I live.

We should be shocked and horrified at the bombings. Our hearts go out to the victims and their loved ones with compassion and grief.

But we should also be shocked and horrified at the larger context of violence in which they take place. What would happen, how would the world change, if our hearts went out with compassion to the children of Iraq, of Africa, of the Brazilian favelas, of the inner city of Los Angeles? If we were as quick to condemn the perpetrators of endemic economic violence as we are to condemn bombers? If we were as horrified at the oil company executive who suppresses evidence of global warming as we are at the gunman?...


The essay is entitled : Pagans Reject the Idea of Evil -- How Do We Respond to Terrorism? Go and read the whole thing, it's definately worth a read.

4 Comments:

Blogger That guy said...

Interesting. I also linked to a rather different article, from the progressive side, about evil.

Something's in the air.

9:47 PM, November 09, 2005  
Blogger SB Gypsy said...

Yes, something's in the air - I've been thinking alot lately about evil, and the liberal's reaction to it and about it. I think most liberals discount the power of evil wielded by our public servants to warp us all onto a different (and not so nice) path.

With the whole torture question in the news(is there any question - except in Cheney's mind?), evil is splashed all over the front pages. And the sad thing is, it's not even recognised for what it is. We are maybe too tame, or too naive, to see it shining out of the eyes of a monster.

9:53 AM, November 10, 2005  
Blogger andi said...

great read. it's good to see violence and evil put into a global context - that neglect, poverty and illness are also forms of violence that we typically ignore in favor of drama and explosions.

11:06 AM, November 10, 2005  
Blogger SB Gypsy said...

Hey, Andi,

I just love the way Starhawk writes. She weaves so many themes into it, and then ties them all together at the end.

4:20 PM, November 10, 2005  

Post a Comment

<< Home

/* sjg */ Site Meter /* sjg */